During the Jesus Movement of the ’70s, I wrote my autobiography, titled “CLAP YOUR HANDS! A Young Catholic Encounters Christ.” To my astonishment, a quarter-million people, especially Catholics, obtained the book, and multitudes were genuinely converted as they related to my story. People had a revelation of the finished work of Christ, the necessity of repentance, plus salvation by grace through faith in Jesus as one’s Lord and Savior.
A key section of the book was my imaginary conversation with the pope, trying respectfully to alert him to the exodus of people, especially youth, from the Catholic Church. Here’s what I said as I closed my eyes and drifted off during a Mass.
I envisioned myself standing before the Pope in the spacious, ornate red-carpeted room in the Vatican. On his elevated papal dais, the Holy Father was seated in the massive, antique Chair of Saint Peter over which hangs the yellow and white Papal flag with its two crossed keys representing the power and supremacy handed down from the Apostle Peter.
“Holy Father, we are in trouble, but we’re not without hope. We still serve a living God who desires to rescue and restore the sinking ship.”
“Your Holiness, there are two things that I believe God is trying to tell His Church today, if we would only listen.
“First, our Church has got to begin calling its members into a personal relationship with Jesus Christ.”
“Secondly, the Church has to emphasize that it is by this relationship, and only by this relationship, that we receive God’s free gift to mankind – eternal life.”
I felt a tap on my shoulder and realized that while I was talking to the pope in Rome, everyone else in the parish had stood for the last blessing.
Time to appeal to the pope again
Recently, I watched the movie “Pope Francis,” billed as, “the first time in history the Pope opens his doors to address the issues we face.” Having recently produced The Bullseye Challenge, which similarly addresses the 30 hot-button issues of today from a biblical perspective, it was apparent I needed to engage again in another imaginary conversation with the pope, based on the content of the film.
I constructed three opening points, then pinpointed five unsettling areas from the film:
- Affirm the pope for his vulnerability and creativity in daring to come out from behind the secrecy of the Vatican and utilize mass media like no previous pontiff, speaking directly to a watching world.
- Honor him for the humility and sincerity he conveyed, along with his sensitivity to the sick, imprisoned and less fortunate. His stamina was inspiring as he mingled with people worldwide.
- Since he emphasized “listening” and “coming together,” ask his permission to offer my observations respectfully. They do not align with politically correct positions applauded by liberal proponents of “ecumenism” and the United Nations Assembly, but I submit the following from a biblical worldview.
5 questionable positions
1. Conveying the notion of the universal fatherhood of God and brotherhood of man is contrary to the Bible. It’s emotionally stirring to gather on a platform with leaders from the world religions, but to say that “we are not to proselytize them” is contrary to the Great Commission from Jesus (Matthew 28:19–20). This troubling approach has resurfaced throughout your tenure, Holy Father.
The Bible explicitly states, “There is no salvation in any other, for there is no other name under heaven given among men by which we must be saved” (Acts 4:12). “The love of Christ compels us” (2 Corinthians 5:14) to communicate the wages of sin and the gift of salvation through faith in the finished work of Christ.
Embracing representatives from Islam, Buddhism and Hinduism conveys respect, and we can certainly call them “friends” – but God is Father only of those who’ve put their trust in His only-begotten Son’s atoning death, which allows them to become “children of God” (John 1:12–13). To say otherwise is to contradict clear teaching of Scripture and deny the exclusivity of Christ.
2. While speaking of mankind’s plight, you told us, “our greatest problem is plundering the planet,” implying if we cleaned up the environment and shared more unselfishly, we could bring about a new day for humanity. This is noble but focuses on symptoms. The implied appeal for mass redistribution of wealth plus climate change regulations sidesteps the root problem of man’s inherent sinfulness and need for Gospel transformation.
The biblical solution that must be emphasized is the supernatural power of the Gospel! “You cleanse the outside of the cup and dish but inside are full of extortion and greed” (Matthew 23:25). I, like millions gathering in the documentary, was a 12-year educated, baptized and confirmed Catholic, faithfully attending Mass, yet not “born again” as Jesus said we must be (John 3:3-8). Upon hearing a clear Gospel presentation that included the necessity of repenting and putting my trust in Christ alone as my Lord and Savior, I responded and my life was radically changed!
3. While it’s inspiring to focus on your spiritual hero, Francis of Assisi, throughout the entire film, how much better to focus on the life, example and words of our Lord Jesus? The same goes for happy quotes on “smiling more” and “having a sense of humor” instead of faith-building verses from Scripture.
There is such authority when we quote God’s Word and the wisdom of Jesus such as in the Sermon on the Mount, the greatest sermon ever given by the greatest Teacher who ever lived! “When Jesus finished these sayings, the people were astonished (“utterly flattened out”) at His teaching, for He taught them as one having authority and not as their scribes” (Matthew 7:28-29).
4. The inevitable question of homosexuality surfaced. While it is compassionate to convey God’s unconditional love for all people, including those who struggle with same-sex temptations or have been sexually abused, there cannot be any compromise regarding God’s unchanging, holy standards and the beauty of His design for human sexuality.
Holy Father, please hear me when I state respectfully but emphatically that you do Christendom great harm by your ongoing ambiguity in this critical area. Millions are misled and “destroyed for a lack of knowledge” (Hosea. 4:6). Your recent attempt to comfort an abused Chilean homosexual by telling him, “God made you that way and loves you as you are,” undermines Scripture and official Catholic doctrine.
Homosexuality is not merely a harmless, alternative “gay” lifestyle into which people are born. The Bible teaches unequivocally that it is the unmistakable consequence of rejecting the truth about God and His plan for sexuality and marriage (Romans 1:21-32). Conveying empathy and compassion is one thing, but implying lifelong entrapment and acceptability is like condoning fornication and adultery, which God prohibits and provides forgiveness and freedom from in a fulfilling new life upon genuine repentance (1 Corinthians 6:9-11).
5. Scores of Christians worldwide applaud and desire to emulate your beautiful example in humility, sensitivity to the plight of the poor and intentionality in building meaningful relationships with all people everywhere. There is no individual on planet earth who has the platform you have to speak regularly to throngs of hundreds of thousands, even millions, in settings like you do.
As a shepherd of God’s flock, I urge you to not assume the assembled masses are truly converted Christians! Keep encouraging everyone on themes like family, alleviating poverty, demonstrating unselfishness and Christlike service, but please, I implore you, seize the opportunity to proclaim the Gospel clearly and powerfully; tell the masses of hurting and broken people of the abundant life, hope, guidance, security, stability, healing, prosperity and deliverance found in relationship with Jesus; warn them of the reality of eternal separation from God in hell; proclaim that nobody can be redeemed by good works but rather through repentance and faith in the Person and finished work of Jesus Christ alone as God’s magnificent gift to us in this sin-darkened world (Ephesians 2:8-9).
It’s noteworthy that my appeal is the same as it was four and a half decades ago! The only difference is that the world and the church are in greater crisis. The opportunity has never been greater to finish the task of preaching the Gospel of the Kingdom throughout the world to finally see the Return of our King! I beseech you, Pope Francis, rise to the challenge and lead hundreds of millions looking to you at this pivotal time in world history.